Answered Conundrum Next Conundrum

A new memoir is coming out detailing one woman's addiction to abortion. If you are pro-choice, does a story like this affect your view?

Interesting Question? Yes (1) No (0)
RSS

Best Answer Chosen by Asker

Marked as Best! October 13, 2009 07:14 PM
I am pro-choice, but I fight against abortions. I understand from my own experiences what is running through the minds of women considering abortion and try to warn them about the pain, depression and life-long regret that follows the procedure. From what I read, Vilar's story is about a whole new level of torment: self-inflicted torment, the torment her first husband inflicted on her and her own issues with control based on her maternal role models.

After reading the LA Times story, I think a lot of people are going to misunderstand Vilar. Frankly, I don't think she was addicted, but merely trying to take her place as a mother only to succumb to the fear her first husband provoked in her because of his twisted views on children. If he truly does believe all the things Vilar said, it sounds to me like she was under the fierce, jagged and psychologically abusive wing of a child molester. She was only 16 when they met, while he was 50. The man should be in jail as far as I'm concerned. Calling herself an addict is a way of explaining away her actions without implicating him because chances are good she still fears him.

To answer your question, no this does not change my view on abortion. I will continue to encourage new mothers (who seek my advice) away from aborting their child, but still leave the ultimate decision up to them without fear of judgment. I hope to make the new mothers I talk to think about what they are doing before they do it and let them know that keeping their child, no matter how unplanned, will be a blessing they can't imagine once they get past the fear.

If anything, I'll purchase a copy of the book and get a better understanding of Vilar's story. I have a feeling this book, if read properly, will open people's eyes to the underlying reasons behind her abortions: her fear of her husband and her programmed issues with control.

Regardless of her issues with control, which are only exaggerated by her first husband's manipulation, I wonder why the focus is on her abortions and not the 50-year-old man who began a sexual and manipulating relationship with a 16-year-old girl and scared her into terminating her pregnancies when all she wanted was a family with a man she was coerced into loving because she didn't know any better.
Asker's Rating:
Helpful Answer? (0)   (0)
Permalink | Report
Reply

Other Answers (6)
Sort By

October 13, 2009 05:27 PM
I am totally pro-choice, and no, this story doesn't change my point of view on that subject. To me, it shows that any and all 'right' can be abused, and every positive can be used for something negative, but most of all that that woman is totally insane.

It would be very bad to discuss a sensitive subject as pro-choice vs pro-life based on these excesses. The subject is FAR to much important for that. It's like using pregnant rape-victims as an argument for the pro-choice movement, those are NOT the cases either option is meant for/against.

In my opinion, pro-choice is a wonderful thing, but it shoudn't become the prey of 'fashion abortions' or medical addicts like this woman. Every freedom and liberty should have its limits. Where to draw those limits? That's exactly the difficulty in these discussions.
Helpful Answer? (1)   (0)
Permalink | Report
Reply
October 13, 2009 05:29 PM
No. A memoir, even if genuine, is not convincing. Even if one woman had such a weird psychological twist, it would have no bearing on the legality or morality of pro-choice laws. Consider some genuinely potentially addictive things such as gambling, smoking, alcohol, and tranquilizers. That some people become addicted is not a good reason to make them illegal. In the case of abortion, which is not by any stretch of the imagination addictive, the example of one woman's psychological problems that simulate addiction would be totally unconvincing even if they were based on a genuine professional study rather than a "memoir" (in which anyone can say anything for money).
Helpful Answer? (0)   (0)
Permalink | Report
Reply
October 13, 2009 05:49 PM
I must say I've had a lot of thoughts about the abortion issue. I can see both sides very clearly and it all seems to come down to one thing; religious beliefs. If I believed we all lived but one life here on earth and that a baby who was aborted lost it's only chance at life over someone's selfish desires and negligent misplanning, I would be outraged at the idea of pro-choicers. Looking at it that way, I can see how anti-abortion demonstrations can become violent. However, I don't believe this way. I believe (actually I know for a fact) we are reincarnated by choice, meaning we can come back as many times as we wish, each time learning new and exciting things, or we can choose to not come back at all. Because I believe this way, I don't see any problem with abortions. I would never have one myself except in certain severe situations, like the baby is going to be a vegetable or I was raped or to save my own life, etc.

So, no this does not change my views of abortion, but then, nothing will because of what I know to be truth that many don't.
Helpful Answer? (0)   (0)
Permalink | Report
Reply
October 13, 2009 07:48 PM
Well that certainly is an interesting different spin on the issue!
Report
October 13, 2009 08:44 PM
I wouldn't consider myself pro-life or pro-choice (see my article in source to explain how that's possible) and I don't feel this woman making excuses for her own weakness should be sympathized with or rewarded with great book sales because it's being attributed to a debate that will likely never be solved.

Abortion should never be a means of birth control, however abortion is pro-life.
Source(s):
http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/1381031/abortion_the_real_prolife....
Helpful Answer? (0)   (0)
Permalink | Report
Reply
October 14, 2009 08:57 AM
Being pro-choice means you have to be able to live with the fact that some people make bad choices.
Helpful Answer? (0)   (0)
Permalink | Report
Reply
gno
gno
October 14, 2009 12:57 PM
No, it doesn't change my mind and I am thoroughly pro-choice. But this is sickening!

Make no mistake, despite my pro-choice position, I HATE abortion. I would try to talk anyone out of it. There was even a person I know who I begged not to do it, even offering to raise the child myself. And I really would have done it. It crushes me that she went through with it anyway.

But because this is is a procedure that does (in my opinion) serve an appropriate and important purpose in some rare cases, I just can't abide by banning it altogether (or god help us, try to legislate it since we do such a miserable job with everything else we legislate).

I absolutely can't stomach when people abuse this right to have an abortion though. It's not supposed to be birth control. It's not supposed to be a stop at the drugstore.

These women, like the one writing this memoir, are as sick and mentally disturbed as that mom who has 18 children and lives on welfare. Close your legs and think about lives other than your own!
Helpful Answer? (0)   (0)
Permalink | Report
Reply

Answer this Question


View All Belief and Thought Questions

Ask a Conundrum


140 characters left

Categories

Large Glass of Conundrum Wine

Welcome to ConundrumLand

Please enter your zip code.