Answered Conundrum Next Conundrum

Do Americans have any culture? Other societies express their cultures in their food, art, music and family values. Are we simply a bunch of

consumerists? We buy prepared food, mass produced art, and music that others create? What, if any, traditions do Americans celebrate as their own?
Interesting Question? Yes (0) No (0)
RSS

Best Answer Chosen by Asker

Marked as Best! February 09, 2010 12:31 AM
I think it's hard to pin down "American" culture because we're a huge country. A lot of Europeans don't seem to understand that our states are about the size of their countries. We are at a MINIMUM 50 little cultures, and most of us could easily say that our state is very divided culturally as well. We are also a mash of immigrants, though many other countries are too. It's also easy for us to romanticize other countries having "more culture" than we do, but that's really not accurate. Culture is not a matter of more or less, and just about every other developed nation buys mass produced crap too. (Seriously, go to Italy and take a gander at all the ridiculous, cheap little pieces of plastic they put the Pope's face on).

I would say some things that speak to a general American culture would be a sense of personal freedom and independence (individual choice, for better or for worse), a general sense of adventure and roaming (I'm pretty sure we can safely say we invented the modern road trip), a respect for nature's grandeur (our National parks are pretty unrivaled, if I do say so myself, and our love of them is pretty across the board), and a great diversity of ideas being allowed out into the open.

Remember too that jazz started in America, as a mash of creole and African American music, American country music (love it or hate it) is pretty unique to us, and the world's modern sense of rock and roll pretty much started with Elvis.

Food-wise, we have contributed some pretty unappealing things (Twinkies come to mind), but our development of things like mass produced frozen foods pretty much fed the nation during World War II, and brought meat and fish to people who otherwise could not have gotten safe, fresh-tasting protein. We have also developed some great stuff by combining all of our cultural backgrounds: Louisiana's gumbo, so called Tex-Mex, the mash of European traditions that created the Reuben sandwich in New York, etc.

As for art, we have artists everywhere! Glass artists, sculptors, painters, singers, poets, authors...we're literally crawling with them!

We were also the home to the first airplane, the internet, and countless modern technologies that connected people to each other. You could say the idea of a global community came out of America, and we have championed things like uncensored information and freedom to communicate.

Our family values are as different as the number of families that we have, but that's part of our culture too: we choose who to be. We don't believe that you have a set destiny. We believe that you have the right to try to be who you want to be.

We are a young country, so we don't have the 1,000 year old buildings that some people do, or the 500 year old paintings. We don't even have a lot of shared history. But for a young country, we have a lot to experience. You could spend your entire life traveling from city to city, town to town, just trying to get a handle on their mainstream culture (ignoring all of the underground, or "subcultural" groups), and you would die of old age before you really understood even a quarter of them. You can literally make a living in this country studying subcultures and then explaining them to other people.

Gotta love it!
Asker's Rating:
• I absolutely loved your answer. What a great way to sum up the things that make the US and Americans great? Thank you!
Helpful Answer? (1)   (0)
Permalink | Report
Reply
February 12, 2010 05:28 AM
What a great answer!
Report

Other Answers (7)
Sort By

February 09, 2010 12:33 AM
Americans have many unique cultural phenomena, many of which foreigners like to make fun of:

Halloween, high school proms, homecoming, American football, tailgating parties, baseball, basketball, sororities and fraternities

country music, rock and roll music, gospel music

apple pie, hot dogs, popcorn, hamburgers, turkey with stuffing, mash potatoes, pizza, coca cola, milk shakes

the diner, the car hop restaurant, the drive through restaurant, the drive-in theater

movies, television, radio, and automobiles -- all invented in America

Basically, if you see it in a 1950's movie or TV show, it's American!
Helpful Answer? (1)   (0)
Permalink | Report
Reply
February 09, 2010 12:36 AM
After spending time in the US some years ago, I thought a little bit about this question. The conclusion I came to was that one of the US's defining cultures back then (early 2000s) was a desire for, well, being bigger, and being better. The last of these is largely worth preserving and cherishing, the former maybe less so.

That all said, the US is still a young nation, and is now such a melting pot for so many nationalities etc. that it is hard for any one definitive, common culture / tradition to filter through. Most other nations have singular demographic groups, with singular definite, inherent cultures and traditions all of their own.

Whether or not Americans have culture is one thing, but there is no doubt that they appreciate it and value it (just look at Mahalo / Conundrumland for proof!). Are / were there issues entrenched within US society that somehow hindered the development of culture from within the US? Was it too eager to establish itself as an economic power? Did issues like the Cold War, Vietnam etc. somehow stunt the growth of culture?

I think the US is proof that a nation can find its feet very quickly in terms of economics, industry etc., but "culture" may take a little longer to grow and flourish.
Source(s):
Personal viewpoint
Helpful Answer? (1)   (0)
Permalink | Report
Reply
February 09, 2010 05:08 AM
Well, being an American and a fan of history as well let me just say this: No other country in the world has helped other countries in need and given so much to others in need as this one! Ever. Just look at the money we have raised in such a short time for Haiti, and our military is there on a humanitarian mission right now. So I suppose you could say we have the value of charity. Foods that are traditional, well let's see there is: bar b que, apple pie, fried chicken, Turkey, and all the fixins on Thanksgiving. I grew up on a farm where we grew our own food. We have the Fourth of July and all it's glory. Martin Luther King Jr. Day, Mothers Day. Hmm. Let's see, I believe blues and jazz and rock n roll were born here too. As far as Art goes, we have some of the best collections of Art in our Museums found throughout the world. When it comes to Fashion, you often hear New York, Paris and Milan. Inventions, the cotton gin, peanut butter, popcorn, the internet! Our country is young and it is comprised of people of every nation on earth but it was born in the pursuit of happiness and freedom for all, it may not be perfect, but it is dynamic and you don't have hide to worship as you choose, we all make decisions together we vote in elections and we vote with our dollars. We protest what we don't like, we stand up for what we believe in and we help others in need. We make this country what it is and we can change it too. I am proud to be an American. Thank you very much. Oh, and I have enough Native American blood in me to actually enlisted in a tribe but you aren't going to hear me crying about it!
Helpful Answer? (1)   (0)
Permalink | Report
Reply
February 09, 2010 06:42 AM
I am not an American, but I have always been and always will be a great defender and proponent of the United States of America. I have spent time in the US as a child, as a teenager and as an adult. I travel regularly to the U.S., I have family that resides in the U.S., my work involves frequent contact with Americans.

It saddens me to see a truly mighty nation not look at itself with the pride that it should. You are not just a nation built around consumerism. You are the land of Washington, Adams, Hamilton and Jefferson.

Be you the descendant of a passenger on the Mayflower, the descendant of a slave, or a first generation immigrant from Vietnam, a third generation immigrant from Italy, or a second generation Mexican immigrant; the core ideals of personal freedom, empowerment of the individual, and self reliance are key threads of your national identity that they can all share, use and promote.

The concept that all is possible, that one can right any wrong, that individual freedom trumps all... that is your culture.
Helpful Answer? (1)   (0)
Permalink | Report
Reply
February 09, 2010 07:34 AM
Americans have lots of culture! A quick browse through a video store will pinpoint several different ways of American living and American ideals. That being said, being a consumerist is a privileged and elevated position in the world. Is there really anything better you can be? There simply isn't any other way to have the best of everything the world has to offer.
Helpful Answer? (1)   (0)
Permalink | Report
Reply
February 10, 2010 01:22 AM
we are may cultures living together sometimes in harmony, sometimes discord.
Helpful Answer? (0)   (0)
Permalink | Report
Reply
February 12, 2010 05:37 AM

I doubt a nation as culturally bankrupt as the question implies would have rescued a world at war from despotism and tyranny - twice.

And a nation without cultural values and traditions wouldn't have labored so long and hard to develop the inmight not only to stare down communism, but also to enhance the lives of so many worldwide with our technology and agriculture.

The Industrial Revolution couldn't have happened in a nation without culture - a people without culture could have no drive, no work ethic.  One of the great hallmarks of American culture is that great work ethic - is there a developed nation whose workers spend more time on the job?

It's fashionable to accuse the United States for its shortcomings, but to follow the lead of "It's a Wonderful Life," try to imagine a world in which there was no United States - for instance, if the North had not prevailed and the Confederacy had split from the USA, making two nations where there'd been only one.

 


Helpful Answer? (1)   (0)
Permalink | Report
Reply

Answer this Question


View All Belief and Thought Questions

Ask a Conundrum


140 characters left

Categories

Large Glass of Conundrum Wine

Welcome to ConundrumLand

Please enter your zip code.