Answered Conundrum Next Conundrum
Can mentioning products or brand names in a positive or negative light be considered advertising? What if there is no financial incentive?
Some people believe mentioning specific products, brands or companies in answers can be considered advertising and shouldn't be done. I consider this not only to be incorrect, but somewhat harmful too. Without specific information, the value of certain statements can go right to zero. What do you think?
Interesting Question?
Yes (0)
No (0)
RSS
Best Answer Chosen by Asker
Marked as Best!
October 04, 2009 05:56 AM
Helpful Answer?
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
It's only bad form if the company has paid you in order to mention them. Blogvertising has become all the rage, and it's a practice I wholeheartedly disagree with. The FTC is planning to crack down on these things by making it mandatory that if you were paid for your review, you must admit that publicly. Who can prove it though?
As far as in answers to questions online? You absolutely HAVE to give brand names sometimes.
I wrote this article about Alternative Uses for Dawn Dishwashing Detergent. You can read if here if interested:
http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/76242/dawn_dishwashing_detergent_its_not.html
The point in mentioning this is: some of these things I suggest people to do I would never, EVER suggest they do with other products. For example, Dawn has been tested as safe on animals, so when I recommend it for washing fleas off puppies and kittens, I know it's safe. I can't guarantee the same about just any dishwashing detergent.
Now, is it advertising to mention a product? Sure it is. It's the oldest and by far best method of advertising for a company ever: Word Of Mouth Advertising.
The point is, if a product impresses you sufficiently to recommend it, you only know for sure if THAT BRAND is as impressive as you say. You cannot honestly speak authoritatively about another brand of the same type of product because you haven't used it.
By the same token, if the brand is bad and it was a bad experience for you, that doesn't mean EVERY product like that by different companies would be the same.
So when answering a question honestly, if it's a specific brand you're experienced with, it should be a specific brand you offer to the asker.
As far as in answers to questions online? You absolutely HAVE to give brand names sometimes.
I wrote this article about Alternative Uses for Dawn Dishwashing Detergent. You can read if here if interested:
http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/76242/dawn_dishwashing_detergent_its_not.html
The point in mentioning this is: some of these things I suggest people to do I would never, EVER suggest they do with other products. For example, Dawn has been tested as safe on animals, so when I recommend it for washing fleas off puppies and kittens, I know it's safe. I can't guarantee the same about just any dishwashing detergent.
Now, is it advertising to mention a product? Sure it is. It's the oldest and by far best method of advertising for a company ever: Word Of Mouth Advertising.
The point is, if a product impresses you sufficiently to recommend it, you only know for sure if THAT BRAND is as impressive as you say. You cannot honestly speak authoritatively about another brand of the same type of product because you haven't used it.
By the same token, if the brand is bad and it was a bad experience for you, that doesn't mean EVERY product like that by different companies would be the same.
So when answering a question honestly, if it's a specific brand you're experienced with, it should be a specific brand you offer to the asker.
| Asker's Rating: |
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Reply
Other Answers (2)
October 04, 2009 08:01 AM
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
It depends on how relevant the brand name is to the question. I recently asked a question about chocolate and wine and which combinations work well together. If somebody recommended a specific chocolate I'd be happy with that as it really helps to answer the question.
On the other hand if somebody answered this question about hobbies saying that you should start using Acme branded rocket boots, then that wouldn't be appropriate as any brand of rocket boots would be good (although neither will help you catch the Road Runner)
Helpful Answer?
On the other hand if somebody answered this question about hobbies saying that you should start using Acme branded rocket boots, then that wouldn't be appropriate as any brand of rocket boots would be good (although neither will help you catch the Road Runner)
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Reply