Answered Conundrum Next Conundrum
Best Answer Chosen by Asker
Marked as Best!
November 16, 2009 10:20 AM
Helpful Answer?
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Hmm... well... first make sure you removed all sharp and/or blunt motile objects from the room, make sure there's a back door for the exit strategy, make sure your passport is in order, and make sure the ticket to Argentina has been purchased through an agency with a good policy for anonymizing traveler destinations.
Next get him fed with his favorite meal, and then get him settled in his favorite chair, and put on the cloths that are his favorite to see you in.
Put on his favorite mellow music, and snuggle up to him and...
Start crying.
Real, honest to goodness full real tear-streaming crying.
That's your only defense. Guys can handle anything except the tears.
Bawl like a baby while you explain what happened, and the tears, if they are real tears, will collide with the emotion he's going to be feeling about loosing his sacred memorabilia which is equivalent to chopping off one of his tentacles with a meat cleaver if it is his box of real special memorabilia.
That will stun him, and he's going to feel sick, and he's not going to know what to do, so at the very least you'll have him in a state of paralysis while he tries to sort out the gravity of what has happened.
Then hit him with something on the scale of symbolically representing a beginning to a virtual new box of memorabilia to rival the original, with something on the scale of... tell him you're pregnant and that you're going to deliver and that there's going to be a new child...
If all that fails and he still can't reconcile, then have the divorce papers ready, leave them on the table, and go stay with your family for awhile as he comes to terms.
Eventually he'll realize it was just a box of stuff that was in that box because he never used it anyway and hardly ever looked at it, but he's going to want something equally significant and *permanent* to replace it... like his relationship to *you* - the only thing more important than his memories - so when he calls and asks you to come back... don't wait a second!
But... just as a cautionary tale so that people will know to be careful...
It happened to my dad, who was an avid hobby photographer who wore his camera like a necktie. He had an incredible library of wildlife shots (he could have, and should have, published a coffee-table book) and one day my step-mother, his second wife, was cleaning out what she presumed to be the detritus of his previous marriage, and she tossed a box of his most valued photographs.
I remember that it seemed to take him six weeks to get over it... he was in a constant state of moroseness... always coming up with stories about adventures that had happened around each and every lost picture.
Finally, one day, he stopped talking about it, but he *never* picked up that camera again, after it having been a third appendage for 25 years...
And a year later they were separated... and then divorced.
I think part of the problem was the way she brushed it off with her trademark little cutesy smile, saying, "Well... now he has good reason to take lots more pictures (hee hee)".
Next get him fed with his favorite meal, and then get him settled in his favorite chair, and put on the cloths that are his favorite to see you in.
Put on his favorite mellow music, and snuggle up to him and...
Start crying.
Real, honest to goodness full real tear-streaming crying.
That's your only defense. Guys can handle anything except the tears.
Bawl like a baby while you explain what happened, and the tears, if they are real tears, will collide with the emotion he's going to be feeling about loosing his sacred memorabilia which is equivalent to chopping off one of his tentacles with a meat cleaver if it is his box of real special memorabilia.
That will stun him, and he's going to feel sick, and he's not going to know what to do, so at the very least you'll have him in a state of paralysis while he tries to sort out the gravity of what has happened.
Then hit him with something on the scale of symbolically representing a beginning to a virtual new box of memorabilia to rival the original, with something on the scale of... tell him you're pregnant and that you're going to deliver and that there's going to be a new child...
If all that fails and he still can't reconcile, then have the divorce papers ready, leave them on the table, and go stay with your family for awhile as he comes to terms.
Eventually he'll realize it was just a box of stuff that was in that box because he never used it anyway and hardly ever looked at it, but he's going to want something equally significant and *permanent* to replace it... like his relationship to *you* - the only thing more important than his memories - so when he calls and asks you to come back... don't wait a second!
But... just as a cautionary tale so that people will know to be careful...
It happened to my dad, who was an avid hobby photographer who wore his camera like a necktie. He had an incredible library of wildlife shots (he could have, and should have, published a coffee-table book) and one day my step-mother, his second wife, was cleaning out what she presumed to be the detritus of his previous marriage, and she tossed a box of his most valued photographs.
I remember that it seemed to take him six weeks to get over it... he was in a constant state of moroseness... always coming up with stories about adventures that had happened around each and every lost picture.
Finally, one day, he stopped talking about it, but he *never* picked up that camera again, after it having been a third appendage for 25 years...
And a year later they were separated... and then divorced.
I think part of the problem was the way she brushed it off with her trademark little cutesy smile, saying, "Well... now he has good reason to take lots more pictures (hee hee)".
| Asker's Rating: |
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Reply
Other Answers (6)
November 15, 2009 06:47 PM
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Well, first you see if you can retrieve it out of the trash. Assuming that's not possible, you might want to let him know when he doesn't have any sharp objects in his hand. Perhaps right after sex? Not really sure...but I'd tell him when he's not having a bad day and as soon as possible.
Helpful Answer?
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Reply
November 15, 2009 09:34 PM
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
That is a very hard situation to be in. I would tell him as soon as possible in case there is something that he can do to try and retrieve it that you haven't thought of trying. Try hard to convey the sincerity of our apology. Take comfort that men are not normally as sentimental as women concerning memorabilia. Be prepared for his disappointment and loss to show itself as anger, you may react in the same way if it were you. Give him a little time and space to get over it. Find out if there is some way you can do something creative to replace at least the idea of some of the things in the box. With a little thought, you may be able to make something that will become just as valuable to him some day.
Helpful Answer?
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Reply
November 16, 2009 06:43 AM
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
I agree that you should tell him as soon as possible so that he might be able to recover some of the items. You can let him know how much it would mean to you if the same had happened, and that you have already chastised yourself and only wanted him to know.
Helpful Answer?
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Reply
November 16, 2009 10:32 AM
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
If I accidentally threw the box full of personal memorabilia of my husband I would tell him honestly and apologize for what I did. I know he will be get mad at me but I will accept whatever he has to say. As long as I am honest to him that I have no intention of getting rid of it and that I did my best to retrieve it and the garbage collector already took it so I cannot give it back to him.
And it will be a lesson for me, I know I will react negatively if the same thing happens to me. So I will be very careful next time that it won't happen again. I know my husband well be very upset if something happens to his collections but if he can see that I am sincere and honest I'm sure that he will get over it soon.
Helpful Answer?
And it will be a lesson for me, I know I will react negatively if the same thing happens to me. So I will be very careful next time that it won't happen again. I know my husband well be very upset if something happens to his collections but if he can see that I am sincere and honest I'm sure that he will get over it soon.
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Reply

omicron
I have a box of memorabilia. Everybody does. Mine's Tupperware, and maybe once every couple years I'll find myself opening it during something like a reorganization of a closest, and thinking about what's in there, and now that I'm thinking about it... the stuff in there is *so* irreplaceable in terms of its symbolic value that frankly... it should probably be in a safety deposit box.
What's in a woman's memorabilia box? I don't know... a locket of hair from her first child... pressed flowers from her wedding... all really important stuff.
But... in a guys box can be things like his best buddies dog-tag who took a bullet for him and died in Vietnam. You just can't replace that.
This particular Conundrum question is actually one of the heavier and more significant questions to have been asked, because should it ever really happen, it *would* be a real, honest-to-goodness conundrum...
And now I'm thinking that an ounce of prevention is worth ten thousand pounds of cure, and for the pittance they cost in the grand scheme of things, a safety deposit box is the place for those irreplaceable and invaluable memorabilia.
marisaupa