Answered Conundrum Next Conundrum
How would you handle a mother who always thinks she's right and when told she's wrong falls into a deep depression for days?
Thanks to the economy, this particular friend of mine and her family (husband and 2 kids) are living with her mother. When she (the mother of my friend) doesn't get her way or is told that she is wrong about anything, she gets really depressed and everything, even dinner, turns into a major fight or an over-dramatic episode. She'll lock herself in the room for days and constantly nags my friend about every little thing she does or doesn't do - no matter what my friend does, she's always wrong. For example, my friend will be sitting down and doing her knitting and her mother will yell at her for not doing the dishes because there are 2 dirty dishes in the sink. Her mother will tell her children that they can't be in her (their grandmother's) room because their mom doesn't want them in there with her (which my friend never said).
These things only happen when she has been told that she is wrong or when someone disagrees with her. I've told my friend to move out and get their own place, but easier said than done for now.
The only thing that will pull her out of her depression and over-dramatic state is when my friend apologizes and admits she was wrong (even though in most cases she's right).
So how do you handle a mother like this that you can't get away from and who refuses to accept that she is wrong?
Interesting Question?
Yes (1)
No (0)
These things only happen when she has been told that she is wrong or when someone disagrees with her. I've told my friend to move out and get their own place, but easier said than done for now.
The only thing that will pull her out of her depression and over-dramatic state is when my friend apologizes and admits she was wrong (even though in most cases she's right).
So how do you handle a mother like this that you can't get away from and who refuses to accept that she is wrong?
- In Love and Relationships |
- |
- Report |
- Share
RSS
Best Answer Chosen by Asker
Marked as Best!
October 18, 2009 01:12 AM
personal experience
Helpful Answer?
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
I have a very similar relationship with my mother, but fortunately I don't have to live with her. I take two basic approaches. #1 I refuse to argue & an argument takes at least two people. By the time a conversation has turned into an argument, nobody is listening to each other - only thinking of what they'll say next when the other person shuts up. Simply say, "There's no point in fighting about this. When you're calm we'll try again." Then walk away, leave the house if you have to. #2 Pick your battles. If mom doesn't like dirty dishes in the sink, teach your family to wash a dish when they have dirtied it. If mom tells your kids that You don't want them in Her room, clearly she doesn't want them in her room - wouldn't it be easier to say, "Yes, let's stay out of Grandma's room" than to get upset over something that won't matter a year from now? Sometimes we just have to make the best of an unpleasant situation. This is an awesome opportunity for your friend to teach her kids how to best deal with difficult people. I always tell my kids, "Act, don't react. Be who you are & behave appropriately regardless of how the other person acts." I have to disagree with the advice of those who would suggest committment. When your mother takes you, your husband, & your children in off of the street, you don't repay her by having her committed because she's difficult. That process is reserved for people who are a danger to themselves or others, and there are not enough beds in these places for the people who actually need them - when budgets are cut, they start in the places where people are less capable of fighting for their rights. I wish your friend the best of luck.
Source(s):
personal experience
| Asker's Rating: |
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Reply
Other Answers (2)
October 16, 2009 06:09 PM
(1)
(1)
Permalink |
Report
Having an adult child move back home with her entire family is always stressful, but in this case, I think it goes much further.
I know someone in this exact situation. Her mother is mentally ill, obsessive-compulsive with control issues. Your friend needs to suggest that her mother get treatment. If she refuses, the daughter can have her commited for 72 hours for a psych evaluation as potentially causing harm to herself or to others. She is definitely causing harm to the children living in the house, as well as damaging her own emotional health.
In the meantime, your friend can get in touch with Goodwill, and they may be able to set her up in a place to live so that she can get away from the situation.
Helpful Answer?
I know someone in this exact situation. Her mother is mentally ill, obsessive-compulsive with control issues. Your friend needs to suggest that her mother get treatment. If she refuses, the daughter can have her commited for 72 hours for a psych evaluation as potentially causing harm to herself or to others. She is definitely causing harm to the children living in the house, as well as damaging her own emotional health.
In the meantime, your friend can get in touch with Goodwill, and they may be able to set her up in a place to live so that she can get away from the situation.
(1)
(1)
Permalink |
Report
Reply
October 17, 2009 11:12 AM
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
It sounds like this mother has some real issues! Your friend grew up with this mother (I'm assuming she's always treated her daughter this way), so it's not like she didn't know what she was facing when she moved back in. I'd agree that the mother is probably mentally ill and needs evaluated. Unfortunately, you can't force a mentally ill person into treatment unless they have made threats to harm you or themselves, or have actually done so. In that case, she can call the police and they will deliver Grandma to a mental health facility for a 72-hour evaluation. Your friend and her family would get at least three days of peace and quiet, but the facility wouldn't necessarily keep Grandma any longer if they didn't think she was a physical threat to herself or anybody else.
However, it is possible to apologize without admitting you're wrong. "I'm sorry we had this fight" or "I'm sorry we can't agree on this" will do. If that doesn't appease the mother, then perhaps your friend just needs to grit her teeth, apologize anyway, and try to move her family out ASAP. This tension will certainly have an effect on her children. They'd be better off emotionally living in substandard housing with peaceful parents who don't have to bend to grandma's will.
Helpful Answer?
However, it is possible to apologize without admitting you're wrong. "I'm sorry we had this fight" or "I'm sorry we can't agree on this" will do. If that doesn't appease the mother, then perhaps your friend just needs to grit her teeth, apologize anyway, and try to move her family out ASAP. This tension will certainly have an effect on her children. They'd be better off emotionally living in substandard housing with peaceful parents who don't have to bend to grandma's will.
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Reply