Answered Conundrum Next Conundrum
Two ladies & good friends get pregnant at the same time. One has a healthy baby the other a miscarriage. Should this impact the relationship
How easy would this be to work through.
Could the relationship ever be the same?
Do you know of a relationship where this happened and the outcome?
Interesting Question?
Yes (0)
No (0)
Could the relationship ever be the same?
Do you know of a relationship where this happened and the outcome?
- In Love and Relationships |
- |
- Report |
- Share
RSS
Best Answer Chosen by Asker
Marked as Best!
October 03, 2009 11:03 PM
(1)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
This will impact the friendship.
Even if the (well, let's call her "sad mom") sad mom WANTS the friendship to go on as it is, it won't ever be the same. At least, not until maybe someday when the sad mom is able to have a healthy baby of her own.
The experience I come from (thank gods) doesn't involve any miscarriages, but years of infertility problems. I was so jealous of women who were getting pregnant and having babies that it made me bitter about them--and I didn't want to be! Honest! But I'd find myself scowling at them and thinking, "Why not me?" It ended a few friendships when I just couldn't keep my delicate emotions in check. I hated shopping malls where there were strollers everywhere. I hated babies. I hated kids. I hated moms. I hated everyone who was rubbing it in my face what I DESPERATELY wanted and couldn't have while THEY got to have it. Even complain about it!
I can only imagine the larger pain of a miscarriage. Her grief must be overwhelming, and she will always look at this other baby/kid and know that her baby should've been at that age doing those things. It will be a difficult mourning process for years and years.
Now, if she's a very strong woman, she will be able to see some light and happiness in the situation, but even the strongest woman will need a lot of time. And during this time, the friendship will probably suffer a lot.
How do I know for sure?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Because my personal example is that when I finally, finally did get pregnant, a friend of mine who was desperate to conceive also got pregnant about 5 months after I did. Over 3 months later she had a miscarriage. After her miscarriage I gave her space, and she took it. She understandably didn't come to my baby shower (who could blame her?), and she stopped returning calls or emails.
How long did it take her to really make contact again?
2 years and 1 month. That's when she wrote me three weeks ago to let me know she is pregnant again and everything is healthy and well several months into her pregnancy. She can now talk to me again. And my arms are open to her. But for a while I wasn't so sure she was ever coming back, and she's the sweetest most loving person you could ever know. She just couldn't deal.
Best of luck to you, whichever side of the fence you're on!
Even if the (well, let's call her "sad mom") sad mom WANTS the friendship to go on as it is, it won't ever be the same. At least, not until maybe someday when the sad mom is able to have a healthy baby of her own.
The experience I come from (thank gods) doesn't involve any miscarriages, but years of infertility problems. I was so jealous of women who were getting pregnant and having babies that it made me bitter about them--and I didn't want to be! Honest! But I'd find myself scowling at them and thinking, "Why not me?" It ended a few friendships when I just couldn't keep my delicate emotions in check. I hated shopping malls where there were strollers everywhere. I hated babies. I hated kids. I hated moms. I hated everyone who was rubbing it in my face what I DESPERATELY wanted and couldn't have while THEY got to have it. Even complain about it!
I can only imagine the larger pain of a miscarriage. Her grief must be overwhelming, and she will always look at this other baby/kid and know that her baby should've been at that age doing those things. It will be a difficult mourning process for years and years.
Now, if she's a very strong woman, she will be able to see some light and happiness in the situation, but even the strongest woman will need a lot of time. And during this time, the friendship will probably suffer a lot.
How do I know for sure?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Because my personal example is that when I finally, finally did get pregnant, a friend of mine who was desperate to conceive also got pregnant about 5 months after I did. Over 3 months later she had a miscarriage. After her miscarriage I gave her space, and she took it. She understandably didn't come to my baby shower (who could blame her?), and she stopped returning calls or emails.
How long did it take her to really make contact again?
2 years and 1 month. That's when she wrote me three weeks ago to let me know she is pregnant again and everything is healthy and well several months into her pregnancy. She can now talk to me again. And my arms are open to her. But for a while I wasn't so sure she was ever coming back, and she's the sweetest most loving person you could ever know. She just couldn't deal.
Best of luck to you, whichever side of the fence you're on!
| Asker's Rating: |
• An excellent answer, exactly what I would expect from @gno.
Helpful Answer?
(1)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Reply
Other Answers (3)
October 03, 2009 11:26 PM
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Any change will make a difference in a relationship - marriages, divorces, births, deaths, etc.. THIS situation would impact the relationship as well.
How "easy" it is depends on the individuals. Some people are capable and some are not capable...
Helpful Answer?
How "easy" it is depends on the individuals. Some people are capable and some are not capable...
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Reply
October 04, 2009 09:47 AM
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
I disagree that things could never be the same. If the woman who had the miscarriage actually deals with her feelings instead of burying them like most people do after a tragedy, it could work out just fine. Relationships are only compromised when people let them be. I personally feel that if something like that is grounds for the end of a friendship then the woman will never get over it and it's going to affect far more than just that one friendship. I would hope that real friends could help each other out, or at least be willing to make sure the other gets help.
Helpful Answer?
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Reply
October 04, 2009 07:06 PM
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Hopefully they could continue the friendship in spite of this twist of fate, but it would definitely take its toll. You know, to a degree the relationship actually can't be the same, but that doesn't mean it can't continue and be rewarding for both parties. I also hope that the mother who lost her child could still participate and actively contribute in the other child's life.
Helpful Answer?
(0)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Reply
bestpay
I'm a father so it's a little different. My wife and I have healthy boys but also 3 miscarriages and have found ourselves on both sides of the fence over the years.
It's never easy and it's often human emotions at there most raw.