Answered Conundrum Next Conundrum

Would you loan your entire IRA to your grandchild to build a house?

My 70+ neighbor loaned her entire $50,000 IRA to her granddaughter to build a house. It has taken her 3 years to build it, and may be 6 more months before she moves in. She has not begun to pay it back, and my neighbor has no written agreement with her, and says she doesn't need one, because of "how her family is". I think she's insane. What do you think?
Interesting Question? Yes (2) No (0)
RSS

Best Answer Chosen by Asker

Marked as Best! March 22, 2010 06:33 PM
This is a truly bad idea on many levels. For example, while there are many programs to help people buy homes, especially if this is a first-time homeowner-to-be, you cannot borrow money for your retirement needs. In addition, there is a potential threat to the relationship if the grandchild cannot repay the money, even if the grandparent is willing to let it go, simply because the grandchild may start feeling guilty, and then as a result, resentful.

The only time this could potentially be a good idea is if all the following apply:

1. The grandmother does not need the money to ever be repaid for her to be able to continue with her chosen retirement life-style and/or medical needs.
2. There is an agreement in place to provide for any other children and/or grandchildren in the grandmother's will, such that if the loan is not repaid, it is counted as money left to that granddaughter.
3. The granddaughter is financially trustworthy, and a written agreement is made whereby the repayment is made on terms that provide lower interest to the granddaughter than she would be able to secure from a bank, and provides more income for the grandmother than she would be able to get from her investments.

Disclaimer: the above is intended for informational purposes only. A financial professional should be consulted before making significant financial decisions.
Asker's Rating:
Helpful Answer? (0)   (0)
Permalink | Report
Reply

Other Answers (3)
Sort By

March 22, 2010 12:32 AM
Oh, please, please, people, don't do things like this. Even in the closest family, money problems can really destroy relationships. Not to mention the fact that your neighbor will need that money. I hope her granddaughter is honest and caring and returns the money.

In addition, the housing market continues to be unstable, as does the job market. What will happen if the granddaughter loses her job? What if she has to sell the house?

A retired lady I know put a lot of her own money into a house she shared with her brother and his family. After family relationships deteriorated, she had to move into a retirement home to get a little peace--and lost the money she had put into the house, because there was no written agreement.

If you love your family, and want to help, put the terms of the loan in writing. It will protect everyone.
Helpful Answer? (2)   (0)
Permalink | Report
Reply
March 22, 2010 08:45 PM
I told her that she needs a mortgage, just in case anything happens to her granddaughter, so she would be paid first out of the proceeds of the house if it's sold, or whoever takes it still has to pay her. She trusts her family too much. I tried to tell her about what happened in my family after my father died, and she knows how my sister screwed me out of my inheritance when my mother died, but she won't listen.
Report
March 22, 2010 01:08 AM
First you don't know the family relationship and where are her Parents, is she just ripping off Grandma.
Helpful Answer? (0)   (0)
Permalink | Report
Reply
March 22, 2010 08:49 PM
I certainly do know the family relationship very well. She is over 30, so parents don't enter into the picture. She's a good lady, but still, her grandma needs something in writing in case she dies or something. If this girl dies, the house goes to her mother, and there is nothing in place that says whoever gets that house has to pay my neighbor back.
Report
March 22, 2010 08:49 PM
I've learned the hard way through past experience that by borrowing or lending money within families, usually causes trouble, one way or another. There has to be another way for her to get the money for the house. If your neighbor doesn't get the money back, they might in the end not have enough money to live in. That wouldn't be right at all. The best thing is not to loan money to family that you expect to get back.
Helpful Answer? (0)   (0)
Permalink | Report
Reply

Answer this Question


View All Money Questions

Ask a Conundrum


140 characters left

Categories

Large Glass of Conundrum Wine

Welcome to ConundrumLand

Please enter your zip code.