Answered Conundrum Next Conundrum
You find out a child who your child plays with on a regular basis, was sexually assault. Do you let your child play with him/her still?
Let's say a child, between 5-10 years of age, was sexually assaulted a few years prior. The person who assaulted the child is not in their life or anywhere near the child any longer. Still, statistics show that children who are sexually assaulted are more likely to become the abuser themselves than if they were not sexually assaulted.
Do you let your child play with that child? Would you supervise them closer if you knew this? Would you be afraid to leave your child alone with the other child? Would you let your child go to their house?
Logic is one thing.... fear doesn't understand logic - think hard. What would you truly do?
Interesting Question?
Yes (0)
No (0)
Do you let your child play with that child? Would you supervise them closer if you knew this? Would you be afraid to leave your child alone with the other child? Would you let your child go to their house?
Logic is one thing.... fear doesn't understand logic - think hard. What would you truly do?
RSS
Best Answer Chosen by Asker
Marked as Best!
October 08, 2009 02:03 PM
(1)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
I really want to say I would continue to let my child play with the victim.I have concerns too. If the other kid is mentally OK from the trauma? Will the friend talk to her about what happened? Will it affect my child in any way, emotionally?
I don't want to be rude and hurt the victim more. I know it was not that kids fault he/she got assaulted. I will be extra conscious while they are playing, because,I love my kid more than anything.
I will be closely watching what is going on with the kids as much as possible. I have my own non intrusive ways to know what is going on with my child's life. I will not be the one to cut their friendship.
I would like to say, I will be more carefully watching my kid; if anything, about their friendship is bothering her. Also, will find time to invite the other kid to play in my home to make them both more comfortable. I will talk to that kids parents and will try to know them more.
In any way,if my child is getting emotionally burdened about this other kid (because of the trauma he or she suffered), I will definitely going to find a way out and I am willing to go to the end of the world to protect her. I guess, all parent do the same to their kids.So you can count on me that I will ask my kid to cut the friendship as a last resort.
I don't want to be rude and hurt the victim more. I know it was not that kids fault he/she got assaulted. I will be extra conscious while they are playing, because,I love my kid more than anything.
I will be closely watching what is going on with the kids as much as possible. I have my own non intrusive ways to know what is going on with my child's life. I will not be the one to cut their friendship.
I would like to say, I will be more carefully watching my kid; if anything, about their friendship is bothering her. Also, will find time to invite the other kid to play in my home to make them both more comfortable. I will talk to that kids parents and will try to know them more.
In any way,if my child is getting emotionally burdened about this other kid (because of the trauma he or she suffered), I will definitely going to find a way out and I am willing to go to the end of the world to protect her. I guess, all parent do the same to their kids.So you can count on me that I will ask my kid to cut the friendship as a last resort.
| Asker's Rating: |
• I like your answer because you were honest that it would concern. I know many here say it's not fair and it wouldn't bother them, they'd just watch closer, etc. I've lived this with my child and that hasn't proved out. My own family (my father's wife's granddaughters) are not allowed to be around my son because of what happened to him. It's not his fault. He's never done anything wrong, and they treat him like he's the perpetrator. It's sad.
So while I don't necessarily think this is the 'best answer' possible to the situation, I think it's the most realistic one. Thanks.
Helpful Answer?
(1)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Reply
Other Answers (6)
October 08, 2009 06:09 AM
Don't get me wrong here. I agree with you. But my son was sexually molested, and this has not been how it's proved out to be in real life. There are parents who won't allow their children around my child, now that this has come out.
We fight this in court, a long and drawn out battle, so people know because of this. My son gets treated almost as if he's the perpetrator and not the victim.
So while I expected everyone to answer this with the same response as yours... that is NOT the reality of what is happening. That's why I asked people to be really honest and hard on themselves when answering the question as to what they would do.
Report
We fight this in court, a long and drawn out battle, so people know because of this. My son gets treated almost as if he's the perpetrator and not the victim.
So while I expected everyone to answer this with the same response as yours... that is NOT the reality of what is happening. That's why I asked people to be really honest and hard on themselves when answering the question as to what they would do.
October 08, 2009 05:57 AM
(1)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
I would continue to encourage my child to play with the child in question. That child was a victim. That child does not deserve to be isolated from society, from friendships, and from normal child activities because he/she did nothing wrong! In fact, I believe that ostracizing a child who has been abused actually reinforces the cycle of abuse rather than defusing it by providing loving, caring examples of what authorities in positions of trust SHOULD be like. In addition, ostracizing that child sends a message that he/she is somehow at fault - it's exactly like blaming a victim of rape for her or his own rape.
Truthfully, the parent in me would want assurances that the person or people who abused this child were no longer a part of his/her life in any capacity before I would allow my child to go play. But that would be between me and the parent(s)/guardian(s) of the abused child. Once I felt assured, I would allow my child to go play at the other child's house.
I would explain to my child, in age-appropriate terms, what happened to his or her friend. It's harsh to have to bring that sort of reality into my child's world, at any age, but it would help protect my child and allow his or her friend someone of similar age to talk with about this, so that it does not become some sort of shameful secret. I would try to be there both for my child and for the other child, to answer questions or just to give them a place to express fears, worries, or anger at the situation.
Helpful Answer?
Truthfully, the parent in me would want assurances that the person or people who abused this child were no longer a part of his/her life in any capacity before I would allow my child to go play. But that would be between me and the parent(s)/guardian(s) of the abused child. Once I felt assured, I would allow my child to go play at the other child's house.
I would explain to my child, in age-appropriate terms, what happened to his or her friend. It's harsh to have to bring that sort of reality into my child's world, at any age, but it would help protect my child and allow his or her friend someone of similar age to talk with about this, so that it does not become some sort of shameful secret. I would try to be there both for my child and for the other child, to answer questions or just to give them a place to express fears, worries, or anger at the situation.
(1)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Reply
October 08, 2009 06:07 AM
I couldn't agree more. However, it's important to note, I expected answers like this one and like gjp's, but the reality isn't proving out what I'm seeing in these two answers.
Report
October 11, 2009 09:44 AM
While I understand everything your saying and this is a great answer (it really is) I have to disagree with telling the other child, age-appropriate or not, about what happened to the one child. Children don't always understand propriety and it would be a really bad thing to come out in normal play to the one child, and it would make that one child 'different'.
I think that simply talking to your child about what is and isn't appropriate touching and to let him or her know what type of play is inappropriate and to tell you when something is inappropriate has happened to them, and then watch closely. But telling your child about what happened to the other child, I don't think that's the best course of action. That's probably the mother in me not wanting everyone to know what happened to my kid and using it against him, but there it is!
Thanks for your answer! It was well-thought out and solidly reasoned, as always!
Report
I think that simply talking to your child about what is and isn't appropriate touching and to let him or her know what type of play is inappropriate and to tell you when something is inappropriate has happened to them, and then watch closely. But telling your child about what happened to the other child, I don't think that's the best course of action. That's probably the mother in me not wanting everyone to know what happened to my kid and using it against him, but there it is!
Thanks for your answer! It was well-thought out and solidly reasoned, as always!
October 08, 2009 11:57 AM
(1)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
I'd absolutely let my child play with someone who is sexually assaulted. The last thing someone who's been through a traumatic situation like that needs is to be ostracized by his or her peers.
That said, you have to make sure your child isn't going to be bullying or otherwise harassing this person. He or she might not mean it, of course, but even so, there's a potential for harm. Talk to your child and explain what happens and that it doesn't make him or her wrong in any way. If they're at your house, it wouldn't hurt to (discreetly) monitor them, just to make sure.
Helpful Answer?
That said, you have to make sure your child isn't going to be bullying or otherwise harassing this person. He or she might not mean it, of course, but even so, there's a potential for harm. Talk to your child and explain what happens and that it doesn't make him or her wrong in any way. If they're at your house, it wouldn't hurt to (discreetly) monitor them, just to make sure.
(1)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Reply
October 11, 2009 09:46 AM
I agree with discretely monitoring them... I sort of think every child should be discretely monitored no matter who they are playing with. There are dark secretes we'll never know behind every corner. Still, do you really think telling your child what happened is the right way to handle this? (read my response to @windowshopping )
Report
October 11, 2009 08:25 PM
Of course you wouldn't go into detail, but if it comes up -- which it likely will, if not there then at school -- , you absolutely need to talk to your child before, to use the cliche, the less sensitive people do.
Report
October 12, 2009 06:58 AM
(nodding) Yes, you're right. Absolutely! Thanks for answering again!
Report
October 09, 2009 12:47 AM
(1)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Initially, I would not want my child to play with the other child unsupervised. Granted, it's not the kid's fault and being a victim does not guarantee that the kid will molest other children. Being an overly cautious parent I'm protective and paranoid of anyone that I'm not very close to personally, being around my daughter unsupervised.
I don't allow my daughter to hang around with any adults or kids unsupervised that I don't know personally, except for school regardless of their history. I'm not comfortable leaving her alone with men period. Just my own issue.
I don't agree with telling my child what happened to the other though. Some things kids don't need to know. It is the responsibility of the parent to have the bad touch conversation with their own children anyway.
Bottom line, yes I would. I would be there and we'd do activities together just like I would with any other kid.
Helpful Answer?
I don't allow my daughter to hang around with any adults or kids unsupervised that I don't know personally, except for school regardless of their history. I'm not comfortable leaving her alone with men period. Just my own issue.
I don't agree with telling my child what happened to the other though. Some things kids don't need to know. It is the responsibility of the parent to have the bad touch conversation with their own children anyway.
Bottom line, yes I would. I would be there and we'd do activities together just like I would with any other kid.
(1)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Reply
October 11, 2009 09:47 AM
Thank you for your honest answer. Our kids are precious, so it makes sense to want to protect them. I tend to agree with you about not telling your child. There are some things kids shouldn't know... period. Sadly, some grownups are just bad and they teach those hard lessons to kids long before they should ever have to be aware of them.
Report
October 09, 2009 01:02 AM
Personal experience Helpful Answer?
(1)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
I've actually been through this. When my daughter was 7 years old, she was invited to a birthday party with a group of kids she'd been in Girl Scouts with since she was 5. One of the kids invited was the hostess' next-door-neighbor's daughter, whom she'd been watching every day since she was 3. She knew this little girl had been molested by her grandfather.
The neighbor girl proceeded to go a little beyond "playing doctor" with almost every girl there, even bullying them into not leaving the room. It was "beyond" the normal, just slightly, and enough to really upset all the girls. Finally the bravest one left the room while the perpetrator was in the bathroom and told the hostess, who promptly sent her home. The perp then said it was *my* daughter. The other girls said it was my daughter who resisted her the most.
Did the hostess have any idea this girl, who'd been in her home every day for several years, would do this? No. She viewed her simply as a victim. She really didn't think putting her in a darkened room with them while they watched movies, a room with an empty walk-in closet, was a situation that needed monitoring.
I'm lucky my daughter doesn't have a very good memory. I was really horrified when I learned the specifics. And angered that they actually initially thought my daughter was the one doing it to everyone, until the hostess called other parents. At this point, three years later, she appears not to have many memories of it. Initially after it happened we caught her looking up "s&x" on the internet. We had some long talks about how what happened was not the way it was supposed to be.
In our situation, it never went beyond the group of parents. The girls are still together in Girl Scouts.
So, having been through it, I'd say I would allow my child to still play with the other child--but I'd monitor them very closely. No darkened rooms and definitely no sleepovers.
Source(s):
The neighbor girl proceeded to go a little beyond "playing doctor" with almost every girl there, even bullying them into not leaving the room. It was "beyond" the normal, just slightly, and enough to really upset all the girls. Finally the bravest one left the room while the perpetrator was in the bathroom and told the hostess, who promptly sent her home. The perp then said it was *my* daughter. The other girls said it was my daughter who resisted her the most.
Did the hostess have any idea this girl, who'd been in her home every day for several years, would do this? No. She viewed her simply as a victim. She really didn't think putting her in a darkened room with them while they watched movies, a room with an empty walk-in closet, was a situation that needed monitoring.
I'm lucky my daughter doesn't have a very good memory. I was really horrified when I learned the specifics. And angered that they actually initially thought my daughter was the one doing it to everyone, until the hostess called other parents. At this point, three years later, she appears not to have many memories of it. Initially after it happened we caught her looking up "s&x" on the internet. We had some long talks about how what happened was not the way it was supposed to be.
In our situation, it never went beyond the group of parents. The girls are still together in Girl Scouts.
So, having been through it, I'd say I would allow my child to still play with the other child--but I'd monitor them very closely. No darkened rooms and definitely no sleepovers.
Personal experience Helpful Answer?
(1)
(0)
Permalink |
Report
Reply
October 11, 2009 09:39 AM
Just so you know, (and I know you do, but I'm still feeling the need to say it for others who read), not every child who is abused will 'act out' like this. It usually happens when the abuse isn't dealt properly and the child allowed to work through the issues.
Thank you for your answer!
Report
Thank you for your answer!